top of page
Search

Befriending Our Nervous System

Writer: Maria Checa-Rosen
Maria Checa-Rosen
Oct 25
10 min read

Updated: Oct 25

How Old Relational Patterns Begin to Change


For years, one of my patients had attended meditation retreats and maintained a daily forty-five-minute meditation practice. Before coming to see me, he also spent several years working with a coach, and had learned a variety of somatic practices for recognizing and settling activation in his body.


Yet, when his wife expressed disappointment or frustration with him, or made requests he experienced as demands, these capacities could become surprisingly difficult to access. Her dissatisfaction was easily experienced as criticism; a need could feel like a demand. He would defend himself, the interaction would escalate, and eventually he would shut down. The mindfulness and somatic practices that helped him bring down the intensity of his activation, did not mitigate the resentment and veiled anger, that often remained. He continued to feel that he had been unfairly criticized, leaving some part of him watchful and unable to fully settle.


What puzzled both of us was that he already understood a great deal about why this happened. His father had been highly critical and perfectionistic, berating him for small mistakes while rarely validating his feelings or recognizing his accomplishments. My patient understood that his response to his wife had roots in this relationship. Yet neither insight into his past, nor physiological regulation, had fundamentally changed what his nervous system felt like when someone he loved was frustrated or disappointed in him.


The question for me was not whether he needed better or more ways to calm himself, but why his wife’s discontent continued to feel so threatening. Why could he understand the origins of his reactions, observe them mindfully, and calm himself physiologically, yet remain quietly vigilant and resentful long after an argument had ended? What would it take for these deeply ingrained expectations to begin to change, rather than simply becoming more manageable?


Why Is It So Difficult to Influence Our Nervous System?

Our nervous system carries the imprint of early experiences that may have occurred long before we could understand or narrate them. Unlike explicit memory, which we can consciously recall, implicit forms of remembering are expressed through sensations, physiological states, emotional expectations, and automatic patterns of response. We may respond to the present through the lens of earlier experiences without recognizing their influence. From the very beginning of life, the child adapts to the caregiving environment. Some children become hypervigilant, scanning for criticism or danger. Others disconnect, dissociate or become numb when emotional experience is overwhelming. Still others become excessively compliant, suppress their needs, or develop an unusual degree of self-sufficiency.

 

These adaptations, which may have once successfully helped the child preserve emotional connection or protect against overwhelming experiences, may later constrain her capacity to experience relationships with greater freedom. 

 

As Bessel van der Kolk has emphasized, traumatic experience does not necessarily remain within us as a coherent story. It may persist as implicit sensory, affective, somatic and physiological patterns that are activated without conscious recollection.

 

A patient does not necessarily remember:

“When I was six, this happened, therefore I am frightened”

Instead, she experiences:

“Something feels dangerous”

The chest tightens, she withdraws, becomes angry, submits or dissociates.

The memory is being enacted before it is remembered.

 

This recognition has contributed to an increased emphasis on approaches that work directly with bodily experience. Peter Levine’s Somatic Experiencing for example, helps people recognize and attend to physiological activation without becoming overwhelmed by it. Through different somatic practices, patients can approach difficult bodily sensations in manageable amounts, moving between activation and relative calm, gradually developing a greater capacity to regulate previously intolerable experiences. Such work can be enormously valuable. Insight alone cannot necessarily modulate an overwhelmed nervous system.

 

Yet, as my patient discovered, becoming better able to regulate his physiological activation did not necessarily change the relational meaning that gave rise to it. Although he could now calm himself after an argument, his wife’s discontent continued to signify vilification, leaving him resentful and vigilant, anticipating further criticism. For his nervous system to become less vulnerable to activation, the underlying expectation would also have to change.

This does not imply that the present is always safe, or that our perceptions are necessarily distorted by the past. People do criticize, misunderstand, reject or hurt one another. The task is to distinguish what belongs to the present, what belongs to our history, and how the two may be interacting. This requires more than regulation. It requires that experience become increasingly available for thought.

 

When Emotional Experience Becomes Thinkable

Psychoanalysis has long had a language for this process.

Wilfred Bion described how emotional experience that is initially too raw or overwhelming to be thought about can, through another person’s capacity to receive and contain it, gradually becomes available for reflection. When experience remains in an unprocessed form, we are more likely to be engulfed or compelled to react from within it. The feeling does not disappear after reflection.  Rather, it changes our relationship to it. It can then begin to be experienced as something we are having, rather than as an unquestioned reality that demands a response. This creates a small but crucial psychological space between what we feel and what we do.

 

Transference is one of the ways these earlier and unprocessed emotional experiences become powerfully activated within present relationships. A partner’s disappointment can carry the emotional force of an earlier parent’s condemnation. A therapist’s silence may awaken the expectation of historical abandonment.  What belongs to the past acquires the immediacy of present reality.

 

Early relational experiences shape not only our expectation of others and our responses within relationships, but also which feelings and desires we sequester, and which we allow ourselves to express. An important part of psychotherapy is exploring these less accessible aspects of our emotional lives, bringing into awareness what has remained unconscious or disavowed.

For my patient, this included his own dependency needs. His wife was the one who openly expressed her needs, while he came to regard himself as someone who needed very little from others. Gradually, we came to understand that his self-sufficiency protected him from having to feel the vulnerability of owning a need, and then having to live with the expectation of rejection or disparagement.

 

Allan Schore’s work on right brain-to-right brain communication illuminates how these emotional and relational patterns are also simultaneously communicated physiologically. Voice, facial expression, prosody, timing, gesture, silence and shifts in micro-arousals are continuously communicated between two people, often outside conscious awareness.

The nervous system may register a relational threat before the person has consciously understood what is happening. Becoming aware of our autonomic arousal then, can help us recognize when earlier relational expectations are being activated, opening the possibility of addressing what that might mean, rather than responding automatically to what is emotionally compelling.

 

Peter Fonagy’s work, on mentalization and reflective function, further clarifies this process. Mentalization involves understanding our own behavior and that of others in terms of underlying feelings, desires and beliefs. Reflective functioning refers to our capacity to engage in this process, recognizing that our own immediate emotional experience is not necessarily a complete account of what is happening.

Under attachment threat, reflective function can become remarkably fragile.

I feel rejected becomes She is rejecting me

I feel unimportant becomes She does not care

I feel ashamed becomes She is judging me

 

Fonagy, and Mary Target, describe this collapse of the distinction between internal experience and external reality as psychic equivalency: what I feel to be true is experienced as what is true. The feeling itself is real, and the perception may also be accurate. But it may be incomplete, shaped by history, or simply mistaken. In a state of psychic equivalency, there is little room to wonder about the difference.

 

Reflective function allows us to recognize that our emotional experience can have more than one meaning. As with my patient, who initially experienced his wife’s disappointment as a rebuke, we can begin to consider other possibilities, including what can be happening within ourselves and the other person. As we become more able to tolerate this uncertainty, we may feel less compelled to respond defensively, allowing our nervous system to become less reactive to what once felt threatening.

 

Changing Our Relationship to Ourselves and Others

My patient’s relationship with his wife made this particularly clear. She was not simply a neutral or consistently accepting figure, whom he mistakenly perceived as being critical. At times, she did become frustrated and exasperated with him. His defensiveness and eventual withdrawal would leave her feeling alone and abandoned. Her own sensitivity to abandonment had roots in her childhood, and when his withdrawal activated those fears, her hurt would emerge as concealed aggression. Her response in turn, reinforced his expectation of condemnation, shaped by his relationship with his father, prompting further defensiveness and withdrawal. Each person‘s protective response thus contributing to a self- perpetuating cycle, intensifying the other’s sense of danger.

 

I had seen similar process emerge within our therapeutic relationship. At times, when I gently invited him to consider another possibility for what might have been happening within him, or between him and his wife, he experienced my intervention as criticism. The feeling was immediate and familiar: once again, he was the one that had gotten something wrong.

Over time however, he was able to recognize this experience without automatically assuming that it accurately described my intention or response.

 

Gradually, he could do something similar with his wife. He became more able to hold both minds in view without losing his own. He began to understand that her anger might reflect the effect of his withdrawal from her, while her intensity carried the emotional weight of her own history. His feeling of being criticized might respond to something real in her tone, while also awakening the earlier expectation of his father’s disapproval.

As he became less certain that disappointment necessarily meant disparagement, my patient had less need to defend himself or withdraw. Through greater reflective functioning, he could begin to recognize meanings beyond those dictated by his earlier relational experiences, allowing him to relax his nervous system and remain more emotionally present.


Rupture and Repair in Relationship

The therapeutic relationship is no exception to the misunderstandings and disappointments that arise in other relationships. A therapist too, may misunderstand a patient, fail to provide needed validation or confront prematurely. The patient’s hurt or anger may be entirely justified, while the intensity or meaning of the experience may also be shaped by earlier relational expectations.

 

In other words, in psychotherapy we can also have ruptures. The potential here lies in expanding reflective function, allowing therapist and patient to explore their responses, and to consider previously unexamined meanings.

“What happened between us?”

“What did you experience in my response, and what did it awaken in you?”

“Was there something I misunderstood or failed to recognize?”

 

The examination of the therapist‘s countertransference-her emotional reactions and unconscious responses to the patient -may alert her to the possibility of a pull toward a familiar relational role. By reflecting upon these internal responses rather than reacting automatically, she can recognize emerging relational dynamics without necessarily acting upon them.

 

However,  when a therapist does inadvertently contribute to a misunderstanding or rupture, it might be advisable to  acknowledge her part in it. At the same time, the therapeutic exploration can help the patient recognize not only the meanings attributed to the interaction, but the feelings, wishes, or conflicts it may have awakened including aspects of the self that had been previously disavowed.

 

Developmental research by Daniel Stern on affect attunement, and Beatrice Beebe’s on dyadic coordination, help illuminate that relationships do not depend upon perfect attunement. Parent and child move through moments of coordination, mismatch, adjustment, and reconnection. Something similar can happen in psychotherapy, where misunderstandings can be recognized and explored, opening the way to possible repair.

 

Why Are Old Patterns So Slow to Change?

Even after many experiences that contradict our earliest expectations, an old response can return with remarkable speed. A patient might know that their therapist repeatedly accepted her anger, or need, yet a slight change in the therapist’s voice can suddenly awaken the conviction that rejection is imminent.

 

The patient may wonder:

“I understand where this comes from, why am I still reacting in this way?

 

Ronald Fairbairn, a central founder of the object relations theory, helps us understand why these patterns are so enduring. Fairbairn’s radical proposition was that human beings are fundamentally object-seeking, not simply pleasure-seeking. But for the young child, relationships are more than just sought; they are profoundly needed. The child is physically and emotionally dependent on the very people who provide care, safety and connection.


When those relationships are frightening, rejecting or inconsistent, the child cannot simply walk away. She must find ways to preserve attachment while adapting to the relationship. A child whose needs are repeatedly met with frustration, or withdrawal, may come to experience herself as excessively needy or burdensome, suppressing her wishes or developing an unusual sense of self-sufficiency.


It may be psychological safer to believe “Something is wrong with me” than to recognize that the person on whom she depends cannot reliably respond to her needs.


What becomes internalized then is not simply a representation of a rejecting, or unavailable parent. It is an entire self-in-relation-to-other: “I am a child whose needs are too much, in relation to a person who withdraws, or becomes frustrated when I need her.” Later in life, this internal relationship may organize both her expectations of others and her relationship to herself: “If I need, you will withdraw, therefore, I must not need”


Another adaptation is to become excessively dependent, seeking from others the responsiveness and gratification that were missing in childhood.


In both cases, these internalized relational expectations and self-states may remain largely outside conscious awareness, continuing to shape how a person experiences herself and relates to others.


What Then Actually Changes?

These deeply internalized relational patterns change slowly, and their transformation may never be complete. Perhaps what matters most is not that our old reactions disappear, but that we no longer experience them with the same unquestioned certainty.

The old alarm may still arrive.  What changes is its authority. 


We are less compelled to experience that alarm as an unquestioned description of reality.  We may also become more able to recognize feelings, needs and wishes that we once denied or kept outside awareness. There is increasingly room for another possibility:

“Something in me feels threatened. I know this feeling. Something may indeed be happening between us. But I do not yet know what it means, or what within me might be contributing to my response”.

 

That small space between feeling and conviction is enormously consequential. As we become more able to tolerate ambiguity and uncertainty, we need not interpret an uncomfortable interaction as threatening. The nervous system may then gradually become less reactive, not simply because we have learned to calm it, but because we are no longer compelled to experience every ambiguous moment through the expectations of the past, or driven by our disavowed emotions.

 

Perhaps then, befriending our nervous system involves more than learning to regulate its alarms. It also involves reflecting on our relational patterns, and the feelings, wishes and needs we have kept out of our awareness, so that we can remain more emotionally present with ourselves and others.

 

Because this learning is slow, healing asks something of us that no technique can provide:

Patience with the parts of ourselves that still struggle to trust, held with compassion and grace.

 


References:

Beebe,B. & Lachmann, F.M. (2002). Infant research and Adult Treatment: Co-Constructing Interactions. Analytic Press.

Bion, W. R. (1962). Learning From Experience. William Heinemann.

Fairbairn, W. R. D. (1952). Psychoanalytic Studies of the Personality. Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Fonagy, P., Gergely, G., Jurist, E.L., & Target, M. (2002) Affect Regulation, Mentalization, and the Development of the Self.

Levine, P.A., with Frederick, A. (1997). Waking The Tiger: Healing Trauma. North Atlantic Books.

.Schore, A.N. (1994).  Affect Regulation and the Origin of the Self: The Neurobiology of Emotional Development. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Stern, D.N. (1985). The Interpersonal World of the Infant: A View from Psychoanalysis and Developmental Psychology. Basic Books.

van der Kolk, B.A. (2014). The Body Keeps the score: Brain, Mind and Body in the Healing of Trauma. Viking.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
The Presence That Fosters Growth

There is a question that has quietly accompanied me throughout my years as a psychotherapist. More than any theory I have studied or any technique I have learned, it has become the reflection that mos

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page